Is tourism harming Venice? | DW Documentary

Video quality	The size	Download

Информация о Is tourism harming Venice? | DW Documentary

Название	:	Is tourism harming Venice? \| DW Documentary
Продолжительность	:	42.26
Дата публикации	:
Просмотров	:	1,6 jt

Dear viewers,brWe would like to apologize for the mistake made at 00:48 and any inconvenience caused The line should read: "I also fall under the spell of its more than a thousand-year history"brThank you for your attention,brDW Documentary
Comment from : DW Documentary

There is something just so evil and disgusting when I see a cruise ship It screams gluttonous, obnoxious, closed off, narrow minded
Comment from : Liz

Haha wow The government official can’t make money from all the tourism coming in, but also doesn’t want to support her own people I smell corruption at its finest
Comment from : Liz

I lived in Venice, and I worked as a hotel manager Yes the kind of tourism that is coming now is certainly harming Venice It is not a city for mass tourismbrIt has lost the personality of a romantic city, too many and many rood personsbrRestaurants and bars are mostly Chinese The real venitians are gonebrToo many hotels, BB and apartmentsbrIn the 80 it was still the real Venice now not any more, I fled and changed city 😢
Comment from : GIAN CARLO PEGORARO

Italians would love the tourist money, just without the tourists 😂
Comment from : Te Tee

Greed
Comment from : Carol Isherwood

Just a big concrete jungle I don't want to see concrete and water
Comment from : c perterpan

Without tourist the people living there wouldn’t be able to brLet it sink in the ocean really
Comment from : SCHRUBBE1966

Is there any way to improve the closed captioning for this video? It is terrible basically any time an Italian is speaking
Comment from : Natalia Lipowska

So many people want to have this "European Fairytale" fantasy slapped on themselves to achieve this illusion that they "made it"
Comment from : Terence Reyes

I'm amazed at how well everyone is speaking English Always so great when people can handle a language other than their native one
Comment from : Chess With Kelvin

I don't understand why more isn't being done to repair this treasure The ancients that built this city wouldn't just allow this to happen They would fix and overcome the problems brFor some reason all this generation seams to do is complain and collect revenue Maybe it needs to sink into the sea
Comment from : Raff

Here is few suggestions to save Venice: Ban cruise ships all together bringing tourists uncontrolled and also limit the amount of tourists coming into Venice annually, and make it pre-booking vacations in Venice like booking a visit to a museum such as Sistine Chapel does, limiting visitor number on a daily amount restrictions Also Venicians who are providing services to visiting tourists should be provided with accommodations, instead of forced to live and commuting from outside of the lagoon And limit the amount of Air BnBs and private apt rentals, to free accommodations for locals freedom to live in their city And above all stop famous Italian political corruption that makes a mess of everything!
Comment from : Mustafa Caycik

nice one! thanks DW!
Comment from : Sirajuddin AM

Cruiseships should just be completely banned from Venice and other popular cities brThese kind of tourists are like locusts, they bring nothing good at all, just trample all over the place and they even go back to eat on their ships, contributing nothing to the local economy Plus, these ships are an eyesore Let them go to other nice cities who are lacking other visitors, like Trieste or Valencia, just to name two random examplesbrIF tourists from cruiseships have to be allowed into Venice, make them pay at least €100/day/person That will make sure only those who REALLY want to see it, come
Comment from : Jump NYC

Yeah is stinks, the smell in unbearable
Comment from : EnterDzehenem

This type of tourism is now abnormal and many local home owners is being pushed outside suburbs for outrageous price estate 🤦🏻‍♂️, many tourism adding more trash in want to see destination
Comment from : Juniel Esparas

Imagine how disappointing it’d be to find this on your vacation There are a billion people and it’s not even beautiful They have their government to blame
Comment from : Amazing Supergirl

Impossible living normal live wen overcrowded and didn’t meter tourist or local populationThat’s a lot of stress which one demolish quality of life,specially for intelligent people
Comment from : Pargev Karapetyan

No matter where people travel too they should respect the destination, care for it, and be considerate of locals, OR stay home
Comment from : D Stew

The gov't at all levels started this One would think they would've KNOWN the environmental risks long before 1000 years passed Someone should find out how much $$$ all levels of govts made, in kickbacks and in tax dollars from the housing, small businesses, and restaurants, and all other vendors who have had a piece of the tourism trade That's also why they look the other way with selling real estate to investors Their judicial system is all part of it for not stopping this This is going on worldwide right now, all part of their latest UN NWO agenda and govts efforts to lower their deficits They only want the rich owning real estate who have the $$ to maintain it or remodel it It's criminal what they are doing to billions of people worldwide
Comment from : D Stew

Losers No one likes a loser
Comment from : Slav S

the solution is to simply ban tourism for a while- harm the economy but you can improve infrastructure in that time
Comment from : Cecilia

And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment: (Hebrews 9:27)brLet the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteous man his thoughts: and let him return unto the LORD, and he will have mercy upon him; and to our God, for he will abundantly pardon (Isaiah 55:7)brFor whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord shall be saved (Romans 10:13)brThe LORD is nigh unto them that are of a broken heart; and saveth such as be of a contrite spirit (Psalms 34:18)
Comment from : Joey Miller

European countries survived by plunder loot and the so called trade from East, now that is not happening these countries are becoming poor Its obvious how they survived
Comment from : Nura P

2022: turns out venice is worse off and crumbling faster without tourists
Comment from : t c

I don’t see the appeal with venice, it’s really not that interesting looking, looks rather boring and I’d get sick of the water after 2 or 3 days cause it’s not like tropical island surrounded by white sand beaches and crystal clear water where you can really enjoy and relax, anyway tourism tends to ruin a lot of things so I can see why the locals aren’t happy and don’t like it
Comment from : lovelyrosebw

Council mostly cares about the profit from tourism thats all
Comment from : Klaudia Grobl

20:50brbrLove this guy
Comment from : swshi

yes
Comment from : swshi

Imagine eating your breakfast every morning looking at that view!
Comment from : Kaleb Krypto

Why not hire a Russian sub to block them? No one wants that fight :)
Comment from : DP

😱😱😱😱
Comment from : Frederika Wells

Preserve first and tourism last always If you want to visit you must respect the places in every way, not pleasing the tourist but tourist need to learn to visit on the terms of the places they visit no one wants anyone to come to thier home and destroy it City needs to seek the best interest of thier people
Comment from : S R

I’m here from the future, and let me tell you the Covid-19 pandemic, was the best thing to happen to Venice No more tourists and big cruise ships in the city’s waters I heard it was so great that during the lockdown, the city was so dead, that even Dolphins were swinging up the waterways
Comment from : Johnny Flores

In next 10, 20 or 30 years, local are driven out of the city due to pollution and rising property price; Venice turns to ghost town and tourists stop to come, at the same time sea level keeps rising eventually flooded the whole city Local government just wanted to pocket money now and not care about the future - GREED
Comment from : wongsinghowe

If this guy who started this citizen group would put the same amount of effort into finding a job that would pay him enough to live, he wouldn’t be in this position… Some people just need to be victims, to make their life worth living…
Comment from : M R

Like any of these places the historical feel of the place is taken away by so many tourists I don't think I would bother going
Comment from : Gary P

How about now? Still lots of tourist?
Comment from : Janka Vlogs

Well do you know how much pollution is created by those ships They should close it for 6 month period, especially the summer… only Venetians should be allowed in or Italians I hate tourism, but it brings money to region But I mean they are ruining the country
Comment from : I think

Thanks again DW for another fine documentary! I'm becoming a big fan of them
Comment from : tootired76

In 2021 it's a much better place, calm, collected and unattended More like a ghost city somehow br The locals' prayers were answered when they prayed away the tourists because not only God answered them with the infamous miraculous COVID-19 which kept tourists away but the miracle also killed about 2/3 of its local population of old people br And we know, these areas were heavily hit and were hit more than twice and it might still be as God continues answering their prayersbr Even government officials were swept with its old population on that last farewell Bon voyage along with the shipsbr So u go there now for Xmas 2021, it's a ghost town!
Comment from : SMatai2c

I wonder how are they doing during covid
Comment from : Just Meh

Welcome to life in the 21st century near any resort or tourist area
Comment from : aureliusVA

And covid happened
Comment from : Ricky Gervais Said Hi

there is no decency on capitalism it puts the state and its force (aka police) against the public interest
Comment from : Leonardo Henrique

If the city council cannot afford to renovate housing, rather than leave it empty, why not sell them to locals at a lower price with an agreement that they have to renovate the property, live in it and if they sell it the apartment must go to another local?
Comment from : Giles Dunk

Definitely a theme park, feel sorry for the locals!
Comment from : Fiona McDonagh

Solution - high class tourism Less people- same moneybrOh wait - you would be able to afford it brFunny to forget how much it costst to keep the city from sinkingbrGood luck living in downtown Munich - but that city is not sinking
Comment from : Michael H

Sounds like Sylvia isn’t a native Venetian, she sounds German or possibly Austrian Just thought it seems a bit odd that she would be concerned about tourist when she was one that ended up staying Personally, I would love to live in Italia (full time) and support the people in any way I could
Comment from : MyCommentsWereBlocked

next time, just have them speak their own language & use captionsthis shitty english way isnt working
Comment from : Ted Backus

No 10000 years history,
Comment from : Eugene Pelle

jeez, why do they hate cruise ships so much
Comment from : Колзак Микхаылов

Now I'm sure no ships and tourist for two years I hope that helped Venice City to recover
Comment from : Claris Montegue

How can that city be in the RED for 800 million Euros? They have millions of tourists! brThat woman that paid for renovations herself is great, because she pays ZERO RENT! It would be fantastic to have this opportunity in New York City
Comment from : Andra Toma

Hey Italian Karen the other tour guides are WORKING for their tips! They need to eat also! Not only you
Comment from : Andra Toma

If you are not financially stable, WHY get married and have children? Really!
Comment from : Andra Toma

7:45 that painting in the background is sus
Comment from : Eric Karian

I not want to meet the cashier from Aldi market on my Journey
Comment from : sandi chiller

Millions of 3thrdclass can afford these price Millions of them have no brain in what they invest their little money to sendbrWhatsApp messages home to their remaining 3thrd Class members This is a business model not a real shipping tour
Comment from : sandi chiller

I mean climate change is going to sink venice anyway, whats the harm in one little extra fuckery with cruise ships, all in the service of our corporate overlords, all hail our corporate overlords™
Comment from : gay_rtz420™

I now have to be careful of clicking on your channel
Comment from : Kiki

Paying the cost of tourism development
Comment from : Elvira Araneta Solera

That Counselor of Tourism was hilarious! She basically said that they were heavily in debt so they won't put money into new subsidiaries HUH?? what?? No one was asking for anything new!!! They want what they have fixedthey want to be protected OBVIOUSLY the debt isn't from helping the locals so where did the huge debt come from?? brI always thought Venice was suppose to be beautiful and romantic
Comment from : dirty halo

1 minute in and it's making me feel claustrophobic The people, the cruise ships, the water😦 me stop the cruise shipshave a certain amount of hours 9am until 4pm in the day that visitors are allowed in and 1 day off with no tourists
Comment from : Jayne Stag

I was lucky enough to visit Venice last September it was Incredible experience
Comment from : kitty 1905

locals always get the end of the stick once the tourists in herds arrive it never fails-tourism in small scale absolutely but greed trumps and locals pay the consequences
Comment from : Abi Brown

Wait the world will soon turn into Venice melting glaciers 😡
Comment from : Upkar Jaiswal

How is the city 800 million dollars in debt? Are they not collecting taxes? Where I live we are taxed for everything from both the city, the state and the federal government
Comment from : Sassygirl 🇫🇷

Venice is "dream" for foreigners, the reality of the city is rather sad , expensive, sinking , no room, Hollywood should be sued for romanticizing a place that is a complete mess
Comment from : lorelai laval

I love Venice, I go there every time I go to Italy What keeps catching my attention is the ginormous lack of care from the government for the city No restoration of the buildings, no improvements anywhere! Tourists are poring money there but there is no improvement to protect the environment neither the heritage
Comment from : Jeanete Jost Collet

Root cause - too many humans… everywhere
Comment from : dharmabeachbum

Good news! With Covid and all the regulations hopefully more and more people will stop traveling so much and a lot of cities will have a chance to build back We have to take a step back from the mentality that tourism is saving communities Tourism destroys communities, traditions and resources
Comment from : Mizwanderer1989

The tenuous clipper laterally recognise because sheep serologically march beyond a sneaky numeric lonely, deranged scent
Comment from : Cara82 Carroll58

Just visited Venice The few good thing that came out of the pandemic
Comment from : Aeria Cross

7:20 what is this drawing on the door? 😂😂
Comment from : Figgyb

It’s such a shame…the ugly side of tourism
Comment from : Denise Dickson

youtube/Iy8kMhb4bdE
Comment from : Sonia Palmisano

pandemic pause tourism worldwide until further notice
Comment from : K T

It is the fault of the government They should have an abundant tourism industry but it should be sustainable, protect infrastructure and resident’s rights and their culture
Comment from : freespirit

they banned the ships 2021
Comment from : dave goldfarb

Venice was founded after the fall of the Roman Empire about 2,000 years ago, not 10,000 years ago!!
Comment from : Tony La Russa

We thanks to covid no need to worry now
Comment from : sasha mellon

I just watched this 2018 documentary in 2021 … with Covid it would be interesting to see how this has impacted on the city Times change
Comment from : Joanne Hurlock

9 ships every day, thats amazing
Comment from : aloe vera

16:45 The solution is not to control how much an Airbnb can make, but rather to force all Airbnb's to be licensed and control the number of licenses approved
Comment from : James R

4:10 She talks about this apartment like she's trying to sell it It's an Airbnb Here's your place Call me if you need anything Done
Comment from : James R

Competitiveness is good for the consumer You should have a goal to protest for National interest does not mean defending companies that never benefited the public Their only interest is money, so rivals can only make them cheaper 🏋️‍♂️
Comment from : Proof Reader